Source decision 0011 — ✅ As a Member, I want to leave comments on specific words or entire text blocks
Original source · exact version bafyreihg2islcnuip5bb7lldwgkcpsrrdvhqwmr4v6zdkrlzqj6ebsifra · Read-derived block
Classification: story; source kind: story; decision: approve; confidence: high; review status: approved.
Rationale: Classification follows the source’s stated user-facing intent and content; sparse or exploratory sources remain reviewable rather than being merged or embellished.
Review qualification: Source evidence supports this independent classification.
Canonical target (to be published after manifest): Proposed canonical target
Evidence snapshot: original readable text and block backlinks
Heading Acceptance criteria source block
Paragraph The editor can select any text (word, phrase, sentence) and add a comment via the horizontal inline toolbar. source block
Paragraph The editor can click any text block and add a comment via the vertical action strip. source block
Paragraph In read context, the user can click any focused block and add a comment to the whole block via the vertical action strip. source block
Paragraph In read context, the user can select any text (word, phrase, sentence) and add a comment via the vertical action strip. source block
Paragraph In read mode, the user can select any text (word, phrase, sentence) and add a comment via the vertical action strip. source block
Paragraph Media (videos & images) support click-to-comment/link via the vertical action strip. Editors get additional contextual options based on the selected media type. source block
Paragraph Documents support click-to-comment/link via the vertical action strip. Editors get additional contextual options based on the selected media type. source block
Paragraph Comment threads are anchored, they stay attached to their text or block. source block
Paragraph Multiple comments can exist on the same block without overlapping. source block
Paragraph Comment counts are visible in the right margin without focusing the block. source block
Paragraph Any user who joined the site can reply to a thread. source block
Paragraph The editor can select any text (word, phrase, sentence) and add a comment via the inline toolbar. source block
Paragraph The editor can click any text block and add a comment via the vertical action strip source block
Paragraph On read context the user can Click any focused block and add a comment to the whole block via the vertical action strip. source block
Paragraph On read context the user can select any text (word, phrase, sentence) and add a comment via the vertical action strip. source block
Paragraph Media (videos & images) support click-to-comment/link via the vertical action strip. Editors get additional contextual options based on the selected media type. source block
Paragraph We move video settings to the 3 dots. source block
Paragraph Documents support click-to-comment/link via the vertical action strip. Editors get additional contextual options based on the selected media type. source block
Heading Basic flow source block
Heading Reader select word or phrase source block
Paragraph Editor selects a word or phrase or a text block → inline toolbar appears → taps Comment source block
Paragraph Discussion panel opens on the right anchored to the selection → user types and submits source block
Paragraph User selects a word or phrase → inline toolbar appears → taps link source block
Paragraph Link is copy to be pasted (a confirmation tooltip appears) source block
Do you like what you are reading? Subscribe to receive updates.
Unsubscribe anytime